Advanced Search
  • Included in CSCD
  • Chinese Core Journals
  • Included in WJCI Report
  • Included in Scopus, CA, DOAJ, EBSCO, JST
  • The Key Magazine of China Technology
Volume 41 Issue 1
Feb.  2022
Turn off MathJax
Article Contents
Article Navigation >  CARSOLOGICA SINICA  > 2022  >  41(1): 111-123
YANG Yang,ZHAO Liangjie,PAN Xiaodong,et al.Comparative study on evaluation methods of groundwater resources in karst area of Southwest China: Taking Zhaidi underground river basin as an example[J].Carsologica Sinica,2022,41(01):111-123. doi: 10.11932/karst20220106
Citation: YANG Yang,ZHAO Liangjie,PAN Xiaodong,et al.Comparative study on evaluation methods of groundwater resources in karst area of Southwest China: Taking Zhaidi underground river basin as an example[J].Carsologica Sinica,2022,41(01):111-123. doi: 10.11932/karst20220106
shu

Comparative study on evaluation methods of groundwater resources in karst area of Southwest China: Taking Zhaidi underground river basin as an example

doi: 10.11932/karst20220106

  • Institute of Karst Geology，CAGS/International Research Centre on Karst under the Auspices of UNESCO/Key Laboratory of Karst Dynamics，MNR & GZAR，Guilin，Guangxi 541004，China

Funds:

 DD20190326

 41502252

 2018GXNSFAA294015

  • Received Date: 2021-09-12
  • Publish Date: 2022-02-25
    Abstract
  • The karst mountainous area in Southwest China is rich in groundwater resources. Finding out the amount of groundwater resources is the basis of scientific management of water resources. The evaluation methods of groundwater resources in karst mountainous areas are diverse with different the calculation processes， and hence the evaluation results are also different. At present， there is no comparative analysis of specific case for different evaluation methods， so it is impossible to horizontally compare the calculation accuracy and adaptability of these methods. Taking the Zhaidi underground river basin as the research object， and four different evaluation methods （total discharge， base flow segmentation， runoff modulus and numerical model） were used to evaluate the groundwater resources in the basin. The evaluation mechanism and process of each method were analyzed. Besides， the main influencing factors of these methods and their applicability were discussed. Zhaidi underground river system， located in Lingchuan county， Guilin City， is a typical karst underground river basin in the karst area of Southwest China. The underground water in this region generally flows from north to south， receives the supply of atmospheric precipitation， flows along karst fissures and pipelines， exposes itself in Shuiniue， Dongjiao， Xiaofu and other places. And then it converges with surface streams and ditches， turns underground again in Konglianshan and Xiangshuiyan， and is finally discharged in the outlet of Zhaidi underground river. The evaluation data come from the test site of "Guangxi Haiyang-Zhaidi test base" hosted by Karst Institute of China Geological Survey. The automatic monitor was used to monitor the changes of groundwater level and flow. The data were selected from the long-term observation data of groundwater from 2009 to 2019， including those from the observation points of karst spring and outlet flow of underground river. The year of 2018 was taken as the normal year for groundwater resources calculation. The evaluation results show that for the karst mountainous area in Southwest China， the base flow segmentation method is simple and fast， but the calculation results are smaller than those of other algorithms. The main influencing factors of this method are the segmentation algorithm and the dynamic change of groundwater. This algorithm is limited by the conditions of hydrological stations and the rapid rise and fall of groundwater in karst mountainous area. It can be applied to the evaluation of groundwater resources in dry season due to its deficiencies of the evaluation in rainy season. The evaluation result of the total discharge method is relatively accurate， but this method needs a heavy workload with high investigation accuracy and large consumption of time and manpower. Therefore， a total discharge method is mainly applied to the evaluation of water resources in a specific period of time or in small-scale investigation and research. In this method， it is also necessary to find out the groundwater runoff and discharge path， and master the hydraulic connection of each discharge point. The numerical model method is efficient， but needs a lot of preliminary investigation and research data. According to the hydraulic characteristics of frequent conversion between surface water and groundwater in karst area， the model algorithm needs to be improved. The runoff modulus method is highly applicable to karst areas， but there is a certain uncertainty in the selection of parameters， which has a great impact on the evaluation results. For the area lacking monitoring stations， the analogy method needs to be used to calculate the runoff modulus in combination with the measured data， but showing certain subjectivity. Determining the calculation parameters is a key step in water resources evaluation. The parameter accuracy and calculation efficiency can be improved through the measured flow regression and grey clustering method.

     

    • YANG Yang,ZHAO Liangjie,PAN Xiaodong,et al.Comparative study on evaluation methods of groundwater resources in karst area of Southwest China: Taking Zhaidi underground river basin as an example[J].Carsologica Sinica,2022,41(01):111-123.
    FullText(HTML)
  • loading
    • References(36)
  • 卢耀如，张凤娥，刘长礼，童国榜，张云.中国典型地区岩溶水资源及其生态水文特性［J］.地球学报，2006，27（5）：393-402.

    LUYaoru， ZHANGFeng'e， LIUChangli， TONGGuobang， ZHANGYun. Karst water resources in typical areas of China and Their Eco-hydrological characteristics［J］. Eath Science-Journal of China University of Geosciences， 2006， 27（5）：393-402.
    蒋忠诚，夏日元，时坚，裴建国，何师意，梁彬.西南岩溶地下水资源开发利用效应与潜力分析［J］. 地球学报， 2006，31（6）：860-868.

    JIANGZhongcheng， XIARiyuan， SHIJian， PEIJianguo， HEShiyi， LIANGBin. The application effects and exploitation capacity of karst underground water resources in Southwest China［J］.Acta Geoscientica Sinica，2006，31（6）：860-868.
    陈飞，徐翔宇，羊艳，李素环，丁跃元，郦建强，李原园.中国地下水资源演变趋势及影响因素分析［J］. 水科学进展，2020，31（6）： 811-819.

    CHENFei， XUXiangyu， YANGYan， LISuhuan， DINGYueyuan， LIJianqiang， LIYuanyuan. Investigation on the evolution trends and influencing factors of groundwater resources in China［J］. Advances in Water Science， 2020， 31（6）： 811-819.
    AndreoB， VíasJ， DuránJ J， JiménezP， pez-GetaJ A L， CarrascoF. Methodology for groundwater recharge assessment in carbonate aquifers： application to pilot sites in southern Spain ［J］. Hydrogeology Journal，2008， 16：911-925.
    Martos-RosilloS， González-RamónA， Jiménez-GavilánP， AndreoB， DuránJ， ManceraE.Review on groundwater recharge in carbonate aquifers from SW Mediterranean （Betic Cordillera， S Spain）［J］.Environmental Earth Sciences，2015， 74（12）：7571-7581.
    Garcia-SolsonaE， Garcia-OrellanaJ， MasquéP， GarcésE， RadakovitchO， MayerA， EstradéS， BasterretxeaG. An assessment of karstic submarine groundwater and associated nutrient discharge to a Mediterranean coastal area （Balearic Islands， Spain） using radium isotopes［J］.Biogeochemistry， 2010，97：211-229.
    FarfánH， CorveaJ L， deBustamante. Sensitivity analysis of APLIS method to compute spatial variability of karst aquifers recharge at the National Park of Viñales （Cuba）［J］. Advances in research in karst media， 2010：19-24.
    JeanninP Y， EichenbergerU， SinreichM， VouillamozJ， MalardA， WeberE.KARSYS： a pragmatic approach to karst hydrogeological system conceptualisation.Assessment of groundwater reservesand resources in Switzerland ［J］. Environmental Earth Sciences， 2013， 69：999-1013.
    Andreas Hartmanna， Juan Antonio Barberáb， LangeJens， AndreoBartolomé. Progress in the hydrologic simulation of time variant recharge areas of karst systems-Exemplified at a karst spring in Southern Spain ［J］. Advances in Water Resources，2013， 54：149-160.
    MohammadiZakieh， AlijaniFarshad， RangzanKazem. DEFLOGIC： a method for assessment of groundwater potential in karst terrains： Gurpi Anticline， southwest Iran ［J］. Arabian Journal of Geosciences，2014， 7：3639-3655.
    AndreoB， BarberáJ A， MudarraM， MarinA I， Garcia-OrellanaJ， RodellasV， PerezI.A multi-method approach for groundwater resource assessment in coastal carbonate （karst） aquifers： the case study of Sierra Almijara（southern Spain）［J］.Hydrogeology Journal，2018，26：41-56.
    NazariSara， AhmadiAzadeh. Non-cooperative stability assessments of groundwater resources management based on the tradeoff between the economy and the environment ［J］. Joumal of Hydrology， 2019， 578：124075.
    Josue Jacob Gallegos， X HuBill， DavisHal. Erratum： Simulating flow in karst aquifers at laboratory and sub-regional scales using MODFLOW-CFP ［J］. Hydrogeology Journal， 2013， 21：1911-1912.
    AssariAmin， MohammadiZargham. Assessing flow paths in a karst aquifer based on multiple dye tracing tests using stochastic simulation and the MODFLOW-CFP code ［J］. Hydrogeology Journal，2017， 25：1679-1702.
    Martínez-SalvadorAlberto， Conesa-GarcíaCarmelo. Suitability of the SWAT model for simulating water discharge and sediment load in a karst watershed of the semiarid mediterranean basin ［J］. Water Resources Management，2020， 34：785-802.
    JakadaHamza， ChenZhihua. An approach to runoff modelling in small karst watersheds using the SWAT model［J］. Arabian Journal of Geosciences，2020， 13（8）：1-18.
    刘海冲.水城盆地岩溶地下水资源评价问题的研究［J］.石家庄经济学院学报，1979，3：60-61.

    LIUHaichong. Study on evaluation of karst groundwater resources in Shuicheng Basin［J］. Journal of Shijiazhuang University of Economics，1979，3：60-61.
    籍傅茂.基岩丘陵山区区域地下水资源评价原则和方法的初步探讨［J］. 水文地质工程地质，1981，2：31-35.

    JIFumao. A preliminary discussion on the principles and methods of groundwater resource evaluation in bedrock hilly area ［J］. Hydrogeology& Engineering Geology，1981，2：31-35.
    朱学愚，钱孝星.关于地下水资源评价中采用的给水度数值的讨论［J］.工程勘察，1981，1：30-33.

    ZHUXueyu， QIANXiaoxing. A discussion on the numerical value of water supply used in groundwater resource evaluation［J］. Geotechnical Investigation & Surveying， 1981，1：30-33.
    夏日元，唐健生，朱远峰. 西南岩溶区地下水资源可持续利用对策［J］.中国人口·资源与环境，2003，13（1） ：81-85.

    XIARiyuan， TANGJiansheng， ZHUYuanfeng. Sustainable Utilization measures of groundwater resources in karst arwas of southwest China［J］.China Population·Resources and Environment，2003， 13（1）：81-85.
    何师意，冉景丞，袁道先，谢运球. 不同岩溶环境系统的水文和生态效应研究［J］.地球学报，2001，22（3）：265-270.

    HEShiyi ， RANJingcheng，YUANDaoxian， XIEYunqiu. A Comparative Study on Hydrological and Ecological Effects in Different Karst Ecosystems［J］. Acta Geoscientia Sinica， 2001，22（3）：265-270.
    何师意，周锦忠，曾飞跃. 岩溶地下河流域地下水资源评价：以湖南湘西大龙洞为例 ［J］.水文地质工程地质，2007，49（2）：33-36.

    HEShiyi， ZHOUJinzhong， ZENGFeiyue. Assessment on the karst water resources of Dalongdong underground river catchment of Xiangxi［J］.Hydrogeology& Engineering Geology， 2007， 49（2）： 33-36.
    朱学愚，钱孝星，朱国荣.用数值法评价地下水资源时对水文地质勘察工作的要求［J］.工程勘察，1981，3：6-9.

    ZHUXueyu， QIANXiaoxing， ZHUGuorong. Requirements for hydrogeological investigation in groundwater resource evaluation by numerical method［J］. Geotechnical Investigation & Surveying， 1981，3：6-9.
    杨杨，唐建生，苏春田，潘晓东，赵良杰.岩溶区多重介质水流模型研究进展［J］.中国岩溶，2014，33（4） ：419-424.

    YANGYang， TANGJiansheng， SUChuntian， PANXiaodong， ZHAOLiangjie. Research advances on multi-medium flow model for karst aquifers［J］. Carsologica Sinica， 2014， 33（4）： 419-424.
    杨杨，赵良杰，苏春田，夏日元.基于CFP的岩溶管道流溶质运移数值模拟研究［J］.水文地质工程地质，2019，46（4）：51-57.

    YANGYang， ZHAOLiangjie， SUChuntian，XIARiyuan. A study of the solute transport model for karst conduits based on CFP［J］. Hydrogeology& Engineering Geology， 2019，46（4）：51-57.
    赵良杰，夏日元，杨杨，邵景力，曹建文，樊连杰. 基于CFP的岩溶管道流数值模拟研究：以桂林寨底地下河子系统为例 ［J］. 地球学报，2018，39（2）：225-232.

    ZHAOLiangjie， XIARiyuan， YANGYang， SHAOJingli， CAOJianwen， FANLianjie. Research on Numerical Simulation of Karst Conduit Media Based on CFP：A Case Study of Zhaidi Karst Underground River Subsystem of Guilin［J］. Acta Geoscientica Sinica， 2018，39（2）：225-232.
    杨郑秋，杨杨，邵景力，苏春田，崔亚莉，罗飞. 基于MODFLOW-CFP的岩溶水模型降雨非线性入渗补给研究 ：以湖南省香花岭地区为例 ［J］. 中国岩溶，2019，38（5）：691-695.

    YANGZhengqiu， YANGYang， SHAOJingli， SUChuntian， CUIYali， LUOFei. Study on non-linear rainfall infiltration recharge of numerical karst water model based on MODFLOW-CFP：A case study of Xianghualing area， Hunan Province［J］. Carsologica Sinica， 2019，38（5）：691-695.
    刘徽，唐仲华.基于SWAT模型的岩溶地区地下水资源评价［J］.安徽农业科学，2013，10：4559-4561.

    LIUHui， TANGZhonghua. Study on Groundwater Resources in Karst Region in SWAT Model［J］. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences， 2013，10：4559-4561.
    张程鹏，张凤娥，耿新新，冀俊杰，陈永康.岩溶地下河在SWAT中的概化方法：以毕节倒天河流域为例［J］.中国岩溶，2020，39（5）：665-672.

    ZHANGChengpeng， ZHANGFeng'e， GENGXinxin，JIJunjie， CHENYongkang. Generalization method of karst underground river in SWAT：An example of the Daotian river watershed in Bijie， Guizhou［J］. Carsologica Sinica， 2020，39（5）：665-672.
    梁桂星，覃小群，崔亚莉，陈爽，黄奇波.分布式水文模型在岩溶地区的改进与应用研究［J］.水文地质工程地质，2020，47（2）：60-67.

    LIANGGuixing， QINXiaoqun， CUIYali， CHENShuang， HUANGQibo. Improvement and application of a distributed hydrological model in karst regions［J］. Hydrogeology & Engineering Geology， 2020，47（2）：60-67.
    刘予伟，史春华，金栋梁.山丘区地下水资源评价方法综述［J］.人民长江，2004，35（9）：33-36.

    LIUYuwei， SHIChunhua， JINDongliang. Summarization of underground water resources evaluation methods in mountainous area［J］. Yangtze River， 2004，35（9）：33-36.
    袁道先.对南方岩溶石山地区地下水资源及生态环境地质调查的一些意见［J］. 中国岩溶，2000， 19（2）：103-108.

    YUANDaoxian. Aspects on the new round land and resources survey in karst rock desertification areas of south China［J］. Carsologica Sinica， 2000， 19（2）： 103-108.
    王宇.岩溶区地表水与地下水资源及环境统一评价的流域边界划分研究［J］.中国岩溶，2019，38（6） ：823-830.

    WANGYu. Study on watershed boundary division for unified evaluation of surface water and groundwater resources and environment in karst areas［J］. Carsologica Sinica， 2019，38（6）：823-830.
    任启伟.基于改进SWAT模型的西南岩溶流域水量评价方法研究［D］.北京： 中国地质大学，2006.

    RENQiwei. Water Quantity Evaluation Methodology Based on Modified SWAT Hydrological Modeling in Southwest Karst Area［D］.Beijing： China University of Geosciences，2006.
    BakkiyalakshmiP，StephenR W. Hydrologic modeling of flow through sinkholes located in streambeds of cane run stream， Kentucky ［J］. Journal of Hydrologic Engineering， 2015， 20（5）：1-12.
    LaiG Y， YiS K， LiuW， ShengY， PengX， XiongJ， PanS， WuQ. Non-point source pollution simulation in karst region based on modified SWAT Model-A case study in Henggang River Basin［J］. Hupo Kexue/Journal of Lake Sciences，2018，30（6）：1560-1575.
    • Relative Articles
    • Supplements(0)
    • Cited By
  • 加载中

Catalog

    通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
    • 1. 

      沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

    1. 本站搜索
    2. 百度学术搜索
    3. 万方数据库搜索
    4. CNKI搜索
    Get Citation
    PDF(1475.0KB)
    XML

    Article Metrics

    Article views (1737) PDF downloads(109) Cited by()
    Proportional views
    Related

    Website Copyright © CARSOLOGICA SINICA 桂ICP备05009877号-1

    Sponsor: Chinese Academy of Geological Sciences Sponsored by: Institute of Karst Geology, Chinese Academy of Geological Sciences Address: No.50, Qixing Road, Guilin, Guangxi

    Post Code: 541004 Tel: 0773-5812949 7796657 Email: zgyr@mail.cgs.gov.cn; zgyrbjb@163.com

    Supported by: Beijing Renhe Information Technology Co., Ltd.    

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return